standinfor.me

Email templates · Insurance agency

Email template to dispute a total loss valuation from your insurer

Your insurer has declared your car a total loss, meaning repairs would cost more than the car is worth, and offered you a payout that is lower than what it would cost to buy the same car again. The payout is supposed to be the car's actual cash value, what it would have sold for the day before the accident, given its mileage, condition, and options. Insurers get that figure from a third-party valuation report that is often built on cars with higher mileage, fewer options, or from another region. You have the right to see that report and to challenge it with your own evidence. Doing it by email keeps the comparables, the report, and the insurer's answers all in one thread.

Before you send

  • The valuation report. If the offer letter did not include it, the first thing to ask for is the full report, including every comparable vehicle they used.
  • Three to five listings for the same year, make, model, and trim, with similar mileage, within roughly 100 miles of you, from dealer or major listing sites. Save each as a PDF with the date, because listings disappear.
  • Records for anything that adds value: recent tires, a new battery, a timing belt service, or factory options the report may have missed. Receipts are best.
  • Your loan payoff amount if the car is financed, so you know whether the payout clears it.
  • A check on whether the offer includes sales tax and title fees. In many states the insurer must pay these on top of the vehicle value, because you will owe them when you buy a replacement.
Subject Claim [claim number]: dispute of total loss valuation 
Hi [adjuster name],

I received the total loss offer of [amount] on my [year make model trim], VIN [VIN], with [mileage] miles. I don't believe that figure reflects what this car would sell for locally, and I'd like to work through it with you.

First, please send me the complete valuation report, including each comparable vehicle used, its mileage, options, location, and the adjustments applied.

Second, here are comparable listings I found, all within [distance] miles and posted in the last [two weeks]:

- [Year make model trim, mileage, price, dealer or site, date]
- [Year make model trim, mileage, price, dealer or site, date]
- [Year make model trim, mileage, price, dealer or site, date]

These average [amount], which is [difference] above the offer. My car also had [recent tires / new battery / factory option], receipts attached, which I do not see credited.

Please also confirm that the settlement includes sales tax and title and registration fees for a replacement vehicle.

I'm asking you to revise the valuation to [amount]. I'd appreciate a written response by [date].

Thanks,
[Your name]
[Policy number]
[Phone number]

Everything in brackets is yours to fill in. Keep the rest as it is or change the tone to match how you write.

After you send

  • The adjuster will usually send the report and either adjust the number or explain why your comparables were rejected. Common reasons are distance, mileage, or a trim mismatch, so pick comparables carefully.
  • If they refuse to move and you are still confident, most auto policies have an appraisal clause: you and the insurer each hire an appraiser, and the two pick an umpire if they disagree. It costs a few hundred dollars and often pays for itself.
  • Do not sign the title over or accept the check until the number is settled. Accepting payment usually closes the claim.
  • Keep the car insured and, if it is in a storage yard, ask the insurer to cover storage fees while the dispute is pending. Those fees add up daily.

Or don't send it yourself

Forward the job to myagent@standinfor.me and let StandIn run the whole thread.

StandIn is an email assistant that handles conversations with businesses for you. You write it one email saying what you need. It writes to the business, waits for the answer, follows up when they go quiet, pushes back on the number when it should, and brings the results back to your inbox for you to decide. You don't need to install an app or sign up. The first email you send is already the start of the task.

Hand this to StandIn opens an email to myagent@standinfor.me with the job already written out

To myagent@standinfor.me Subject Fight my insurer's total loss valuation 
Hi StandIn,

My insurer totaled my car and the payout is too low. Please get the valuation raised.

The claim: [insurer, claim number, adjuster name and email].
The car: [year make model trim, VIN, mileage, and any options or recent work with receipts].
Their offer: [amount and date, and whether it says anything about sales tax].
Loan payoff if any: [amount].
Where I am: [zip code].

Get the full valuation report from them, find comparable listings near me, send those and my receipts, confirm tax and fees are included, and negotiate until the number is fair. Bring me each revised offer before I accept anything, and tell me if the appraisal clause is worth using.

Thanks,
[Your name]

Related templates